Before one can fully understand what I’m talking about, one should read The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers by Paul Kennedy. However, as most of you won’t, I will give some faint, sketchy foundational concepts before I get into the good stuff.
The Definition of a Great Power
A Great Power is essentially a country that possesses the ability to defeat in war and/or impose its will on, or over, any other country but its equals (that is, other Great Powers). The number of Great Powers varies from era to era, but their number has never exceeded ten. When one country has risen so far above all of its rivals that it is able to dominate them, then it is called a Super Power. There can be only two Super Powers at a time. After WWII the US and USSR were the only Great Powers left standing, really, so they were called Super Powers. After the fall of the USSR and the temporary weakening of Russia , the US was the lone Super Power.Since WWII, the qualifications to be a World Power are thus: Economic/Industrial suzerainty (this can take several forms), Military power, Nuclear arms, Strategic Geographic position, and Technological Superiority. A seat on the UN Security Council doesn’t hurt either.
List of Current and Potential Great Powers
At this moment there are four Great Powers and two potential Great Powers. The US is the first and greatest of the Powers, but is no longer a Super Power. China is fast growing, and has achieved in the past ten years the coveted status of Great Power.
Russia , while still a shadow of its Soviet and Imperial former selves, has just enough bases covered to remain in the Powers, and is deliberately increasing its strength in several key areas.
Last, but not least, is the European Union (or EU). Composed of nearly all the countries of Western and Central Europe, the EU has enough combined power to blast the rest of the world into oblivion (without nukes, although they have plenty of those, thanks to Britain and France) if only they could agree on which direction to aim. The EU tops just about every category, but is heavily fragmented and the official EU military is very small. However, if their new constitution is approved, there will be a United States of Europe.
The two potential powers are Japan and India .
Japan has technological superiority and its economy is second only to the US . As an island, it is relatively secure from land-based attack. However, its military, while state-of-the-art, is tiny and limited by its post-WWII constitution. Japan ’s population is crowded, and its native resources are about nil. It also has no nuclear weapons (also banned in its constitution), but to be fair, it has an extensive network of nuclear power plants, advanced rocket technology and the expertise to convert to a nuclear power within the maximum of several months. Due to a number of factors, such as the oil crisis (they import all of their oil) and the threat of a nuclear armed North Korea, Japan ’s Prime Minister is seeking to change the constitution and expand the military, and talk of “going nuclear” is growing.
Meanwhile, India is close to Power status as well. Unlike Japan, India has vast resources, and its population is very close to surpassing China ’s. India is a nuclear power, has an immense army, and its economy is booming. However, its level of technology is second-rate, and its military suffers from that. Also, India , while shielded by the Himalayas in the north and the Burmese jungles in the east, has a nuclear armed second-rate power Pakistan on the west. Pakistan is well-connected diplomatically and will side with whichever Power attempts to thwart India ’s national aims. India has several border disputes with China as well. I will expand on the mechanics and prospects of each Power and potential Power in further posts, as well as commenting on relevant news related to the Rise and Fall of the Great Powers. Stay tuned…
Hi
By profession I am a lawyer. I’m also an avid reader of Warfare and Strategy. My reading exposed me to a wide variety of subjects and this took me eventually to read about rise and fall of various ‘super-power’ nations (as you define them). A few days back I decided to take some time out and read about this properly.
I once spotted a book titled ‘The Rise and the fall of the Third Reich’ in a book-store and I have always been fascinated with Hitler’s Germany. At first I though I would start with that.
But then I decided to take it systematically. The first book I decided to read was ‘The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers’, which I purchased today. I ran a google search and came across your blog.
I must say it is very well written and I do plan to read more once I finish the book. As the introductory post quite clearly says one must first read the above said book to understand your blog better, I guess I am lucky I picked it up first.
I guess I do have some ground work in this subject because I have been reading about military strategy and warfare for quite some time now, this new topic has me all fired up.
Plan to stay in touch.
Regards
By: Khagesh Gautam on July 16, 2010
at 8:06 pm
Thank you for stopping by. I have neglected the blog for quite some time, as I have been busy with military affairs for the past year and a half, but hope to get it going again soon. Yes, Kennedy’s book is my favorite work on power politics in the Modern Era, and offers good insights into other historical disciplines and eras as well. I find the ideas presented in The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers to be fascinating, and this blog is my attempt to publicly analyze the current world situation utilizing the principles found in the book (as well as some principles of my own…). Hope to hear from you again!
By: Scotty on July 18, 2010
at 1:00 am